17 Comments
User's avatar
Emily Sun's avatar

Overjoyed to be known as a bringer of rugelach :)

Expand full comment
becca rothfeld's avatar

truly the best!!!!!!

Expand full comment
Sam Kriss's avatar

fully agree that kleist is better than goethe

Expand full comment
Secret Squirrel's avatar

Goethe is perversely underrated because the Goethe-industrial complex makes him seem like such a chore

Expand full comment
becca rothfeld's avatar

Goethe is obviously good, don't get me wrong, but I still prefer Kleist

Expand full comment
Secret Squirrel's avatar

I get it, Goethe himself founded the Goethe-industrial complex, except in the early stuff and the shorter poems he almost makes an active effort to be boring whereas Kleist is never boring

Expand full comment
Eric Kaplan's avatar

I think people can both have reasons for what they write and also be driven by subpersonal and superpersonal unconscious factors. I know i am!

Expand full comment
becca rothfeld's avatar

Of course they can…but is there any reason to think that in this case, they do?

Expand full comment
Eric Kaplan's avatar

Just your standard Darwinian and Freudian reasons for human aggression and its enjoyment. Nothing special about this case.

Expand full comment
D Muthulingam's avatar

I cant believe your BF piece compelled me, a person whose daily reading predominantly consists of consumer review of bathrobes, to start devouring some hella old german gothic horror?!

Expand full comment
Michal Martínek's avatar

Could someone explain the Renata Adler references/variations to a non-native English speaker—it's all over Twitter in connection to the Oyler review and I'm puzzled...

Looking forward to the review—for ETA Hoffman aficionados, check out Offenbach's great opera Les Contes d'Hoffmann based on three of his short stories, with Hoffmann being the main character. It has a show-stopping, difficult-to-sing aria called The Doll Song in the first act, and the most beautiful barcarolle duet in the third act (Belle nuit...).

Expand full comment
Michael Rance's avatar

the barcarolle duet is heavenly, one of my favorite pieces of music of all time!

Expand full comment
SlowlyReading's avatar

Well-said.

Expand full comment
Joey's avatar

This whole thing smacks of gender.

Expand full comment
Derek Neal's avatar

fwiw, I’ve seen the complete opposite reaction to Manov’s piece, but maybe we just follow different people on Twitter/substack…

Expand full comment
Audrey Horne's avatar

yes!!! YES!

Expand full comment